08 9442 0000
Home
Financial Planning
Financial Planning
Prosper Managed Portfolios
Family Package
Money Management Services
Superannuation
Corporate Super
Self Managed Super Funds
Investment & Wealth management
Wealth Management
Asset Management
Age Care Advice
Pre-retirement Planning
Retirement Planning
Government Benefits
Estate Planning
Business & Personal Insurance
Business Insurance
Personal Insurance
Wealth Protection
Working with Provident
Our Advice
Our People
Insurance Services
Insurance Services
About us
Commercial Insurance
Domestic Insurance
Claims
Workers' Compensation
Working with Provident
Our Advice
Our Process
Our People
Client Portal
Client Testimonials
Client Testimonials
2023 Enjoy Factor
2022 Enjoy Factor
2021 Enjoy Factor
2020 Enjoy Factor
2019 Enjoy Factor
2018 Enjoy Factor
2017 Enjoy Factor
2016 Enjoy Factor
2015 Enjoy Factor
2014 Enjoy Factor
2013 Enjoy Factor
2012 Enjoy Factor
2011 Enjoy Factor
About
About
Our people
Leadership Team
Financial Planners
Support Team
News
News
Latest News
Market update
Contact
Contact
Booking
April 30 2020 Market Update
See more
Latest News
Market update
April 24 2024 Market Update
March 26 2024 Market Update
February 21 2024 Market Update
January 17 2024 Market Update
December 13 2023 Market Update
November 16 2023 Market Update
October 18 2023 Market Update
August 29 2023 Market Update
July 18 2023 Market Update
April 19 2023 Market Update
February 21 2023 Market Update
January 18 2022 Market Update
December 15 2022 Market Update
March 15 2023 Market Update
May 23 2023 Market Update
November 16 2022 Market Update
October 20 2022 Market Update
September 14 2023 Market Update
September 27 2022 Market Update
August 10 2022 Market Update
August 3 2022 Market Update
July 19 2022 Market Update
June 8 2022 Market Update
May 18 2022 Market Update
May 10 2022 Oliver's Insights
April 20 2022 Market Update
March 16 2022 Market Update
February 17 2022 Market Update
January 27 2022 Market Update
January 13 2022 Market Update
December 15 2021 Market Update
November 15 2021 Market Update
October 18 2021 Market Update
September 16 2021 Market Update
August 18 2021 Market Update
July 22 2021 Market Update
June 21 2021 Market Update
The 2021-22 Australian Budget
April 22 2021 Market Update
March 25 2021 Market Update
February 16 2021 Market Update
January 11 2021 Market Update
November 18 2020 Market Update
October 13 2020 Market Update
September 17 2020 Market Update
August 20 2020 Market Update
July 14 2020 Market Update
June 18 2020 Market Update
May 26 2020 Market Update
May 15 2020 Market Update
May 7 2020 Market Update
April 30 2020 Market Update
April 23 2020 Market Update
April 20 2020 Market Update
April 2 2020 Market Update
April 8 2020 Market Update
March 18 2020 Market Update
March 2020 Market Update
February 2020 Investment Market Update
February 2020 Market Update
January 2020 Market Update
December 2019 Market Update
March 26 2020 Market Update
Latest News
Market update
April 30 2020 Market Update
| 30/04/2020
WHY SUPER AND GROWTH ASSETS LIKE SHARES HAVE TO BE SEEN AS LONG-TERM INVESTMENTS
In this Market Update, Shane revisits some previous 2019 commentary and touches on recent short term volatility and what this means for superannuation funds along with the importance of taking a long term view to your growth investments. Whilst it may seem that moving to cash makes sense during uncertain times, trying to time markets is fraught with danger and this can be shown by the impact of missing just a few of the best and worst days in the market relative to remaining fully invested.
Shane’s message indicates that time in the market and staying disciplined to the investment philosophy will provide superior return in the long term. At Provident, we consider and develop investment portfolios with the long term in mind and continue to actively monitor your portfolios to ensure we undertake a prudent and measured approach to your investments.
KEY POINTS
As we've seen recently growth assets like shares have periods of bad short-term performance versus bonds & cash. But they provide superior long-term returns which is essential to grow retirement savings. It makes sense for superannuation to have a high exposure to them.
The best approach is to simply recognise that super and investing in shares is a long-term investment.
Introduction
This is an update of a note I wrote last November, but after the recent plunge in shares and the associated 10% or so loss in balanced growth superannuation funds through the March quarter, it’s particularly relevant now. When share markets plunge as they did into March the standard questions are: What caused the fall? What’s the outlook? And what does it mean for superannuation? The correct answer to the latter should be “nothing really, as super is a long-term investment and share market volatility is normal.” This may sound like marketing spin. But, except for those who are into trading or are close to or in retirement - shares and super really are long-term investments.
Super funds, growth assets & compound interest
Superannuation is aimed (within reason) at providing maximum (risk-adjusted) funds for use in retirement. So typical Australian super funds have a bias towards shares and other growth assets that grow in value with the economy, particularly for younger members, and some exposure to defensive assets like bonds and cash to avoid excessive short-term volatility. These approaches aim to make the most of the power of compound interest which sees returns build on returns over time. The next chart shows the value of a $100 investment in Australian cash, bonds, shares and residential property from 1926 assuming any interest, dividends and rents is reinvested along the way.
Source: ABS, ASX, Bloomberg, REIA, AMP Capital
As return series for commercial property and infrastructure only go back a few decades I have used residential property as a proxy. Over the period shown since 1926 cash has returned 5.4% per annum, bonds 6.9% pa, property 10.7% pa and shares 10.9% pa. Because shares and property provide higher returns over long periods the value of an investment in them compounds to a much higher amount over long periods. So, it makes sense to have a decent exposure to them when saving for retirement. The higher return from shares and growth assets reflects compensation for the greater risk in investing in them – in terms of capital loss, volatility and illiquidity.
But investors don’t have 90 years?
But while the above chart covered more than 90 years of returns, our natural tendency is to think very short term. Particularly so in times of uncertainty like now. And this is where the problem starts. On a day to day basis shares are down almost as much as they are up. See the next chart. So, day to day, it’s pretty much a coin toss as to whether you will get good news or bad on shares. But if you just look monthly and allow for dividends, the historical experience suggests you will only get bad news around a third of the time. If you go out to once a decade, positive returns have been seen 100% of the time for Australian shares and 82% for US shares. So while it’s hard given the bombardment of financial news these days it makes sense to look at your returns less because then you are more likely to get positive returns and less likely to make rash decisions based on short term bad news.
Daily & mnthly data from 1995,yrs & decades from 1900. Bloomberg, AMP Capital
This can also be demonstrated in the following charts. On a rolling 12 month ended basis the returns from shares bounce around all over the place compared to the relative stability of cash (and bonds). See the next chart
Source: ASX, Bloomberg, AMP Capital
However, over rolling ten-year periods, shares have invariably outperformed, although there have been some periods where returns from bonds and cash have done better, albeit briefly.
Source: ASX, Bloomberg, AMP Capital
Pushing the horizon out to rolling 20-year returns has almost always seen shares do even better, although a surge in cash and bond returns from the 1970s/1980s has seen the gap narrow. Over rollwing 40-year periods - the working years of a typical person - shares have always done better.
Source: ASX Bloomberg, AMP Capital
This is all consistent with the basic proposition that higher short-term volatility from shares - often reflecting exposure to periods of falling profits and a risk that companies go bust - is rewarded over the long term with higher returns.
But why not try and time short-term market moves?
The temptation to do this is immense. With the benefit of hindsight many swings in markets like the tech boom and bust, the GFC and maybe in the years ahead the current episode look inevitable and hence forecastable and so it’s natural to think “why not give it a go?” by switching between say cash and shares within your super to anticipate market moves. Fair enough if you have a process and put the effort in. But without a tried and tested market timing process, trying to time the market is difficult. A good way to demonstrate this is with a comparison of returns if an investor is fully invested in shares versus missing out on the best (or worst) days. The next chart shows that if you were fully invested in Australian shares from January 1995, you would have returned 8.5% pa (with dividends but not allowing for franking credits, tax and fees).
Source: ASX, Bloomberg, AMP Capital
If by trying to time the market you avoided the 10 worst days (yellow bars), you would have boosted your return to 11.7% pa. And if you avoided the 40 worst days, it would have been boosted to 17.1% pa! But this is not easy as many investors only get out after the bad returns have occurred, just in time to miss some of the best days. For example, if by trying to time the market you miss the 10 best days (blue bars), the return falls to 6.3% pa. If you miss the 40 best days, it drops to just 1.9% pa.
The following chart shows the difficulties of short-term timing in another way. It shows the cumulative return of two portfolios.
A fixed balanced mix of 70 per cent Australian equities, 25 per cent bonds and five per cent cash;
A “switching portfolio” which starts off with the above but moves 100 per cent into cash after any negative calendar year in the balanced portfolio and doesn't move back until after the balanced portfolio has a calendar year of positive returns. We have assumed a two-month lag.
Source: ASX, Bloomberg, AMP Capital
Over the long run the switching portfolio produces an average return of 8.6% pa versus 9.9% pa for the balanced mix. From a $100 investment in 1928 the switching portfolio would have grown to $185,869 compared to $595,510 for the constant mix.
Key messages
First, while shares and other growth assets go through periods of short-term underperformance relative to bonds and cash, they provide superior returns over the long term. As such, it makes sense that superannuation has a high exposure to them.
Second, switching to cash after a bad patch is not the best strategy for maximising retirement savings and wealth over time as it locks in the loss with no hope of recovery.
Third, the less you look at your investments the less you will be disappointed. This reduces the chance of selling at the wrong time or adopting an overly cautious stance.
The best approach is to simply recognise that super and investing in shares is a long-term investment. The exceptions to this are if you are really into putting in the effort to getting short-term trading right and/or you are close to, or in, retirem
ent.
DR SHANE OLIVER
HEAD OF INVESTMENT STRATEGY AND CHIEF ECONOMIST
AMP CAPITAL
About the Author
Dr Shane Oliver, Head of Investment Strategy and Economics and Chief Economist at AMP Capital is responsible for AMP Capitals' diversified investment funds. He also provides economic forecasts and analysis of key variables and issues affecting, or likely to affect, all asset markets.
THIS ARTICLE WAS RELEASE BY AMP CAPITAL 28 APRIL 2020, FOR MORE AMP CAPITAL UPDATES GO TO
WWW.AMPCAPITAL.COM.AU
Important note: While every care has been taken in the preparation of this document, AMP Capital Investors Limited (ABN 59 001 777 591, AFSL 232497) and AMP Capital Funds Management Limited (ABN 15 159 557 721, AFSL 426455) make no representations or warranties as to the accuracy or completeness of any statement in it including, without limitation, any forecasts. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance. This document has been prepared for the purpose of providing general information, without taking account of any particular investor’s objectives, financial situation or needs. An investor should, before making any investment decisions, consider the appropriateness of the information in this document, and seek professional advice, having regard to the investor’s objectives, financial situation and needs. This document is solely for the use of the party to whom it is provided.
Back to News